Ok, so who watched the PBS documentary on the Mormons? What did you think of it? I'd love to hear your thoughts. I watched all four hours of it. What an investment of my time. I kept thinking, "Only Mormons are going to make time to watch this WHOLE thing." I enjoy learning about other religions, but I don't think I would spend that amount of time over a two-day period watching a show about Catholicism or Buddhism.
I was very nervous the whole time I watched. I was surprised at myself for that. It was almost like the negative things that were addressed were personal attacks on me. I was very defensive throughout the program, so I don't know that I am a fair judge of the content, but here are some of my thoughts.
-I was so surprised to hear one person they interviewed say, "I hear the voice of Joseph Smith when I read the Book of Mormon." How do you hear the voice of an unschooled farm boy when you read that beautiful book of scripture? Call me crazy, but I hear the voice of the Lord.
-One of my favorite quotes of the whole show was a non-Mormon man who said, "If we doubt the origins of Mormons because they seem outlandish, we have to doubt the origins of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. All religion is based on miracles." I loved that! Just because our miracle occured in more recent history, people seem more likely to dismiss it or think we're crazy.
-One of the men interviewed said, "Why were the Mormons so hated? It's perplexing." What a good question. I can understand how polygamy would bring hatred and misunderstanding, but long before polygamy was practiced, the Mormons were heavily persecuted. And they talked about how the extermination order issued against the Mormons by the state of Missouri was the only time that has EVER happened in this country. I think that had a unifying effect on members then and continues to have that effect now.
-One of my biggest complaints about the program: I felt like none of the strong, faithful commentators were women. Where was Sheri Dew? Where was Susan Easton Black? I felt like this was a subtle way of perpetuating the notion that women are second class citizens in our faith.
-I understand that they needed to discuss the Mountain Meadows Massacre, but did they have to spend 1/2 an hour--25% of the first show on it? That seemed overboard to me since it was one isolated, tragic incident.
-The program was very clear in stating that polygamy is NOT part of the church's practices at this time, yet they spent a HUGE part of that segment talking about people who are currently living it. That was confusing.
-I've worshipped in dozens of LDS congregations all over the country throughout my life, and I've never sung a hymn where we were standing up and clapping. What was up with that clip on the second day?
-That was a very complimentary, uplifting segment on the welfare and service aspect of the Church.
-They talked about how part of our identity as a church is being a peculiar people, but that we've become so mainstream that we're "wrestling" with the problem of being too much like other religions. I disagree with that. I definitely feel that we still stand out in the crowd and have a sort of mystery and curiousity about us.
-That returned missionary making the "suicide bomber" comment was outrageous.
-I was uncomfortable during the entire segment on the temple. They just came too close to publicizing the things that I hold most sacred.
I realize I've highlighted mainly things that bothered me, but there were lots of good things about the show as well. I love that they interviewed President Hinckley and Elder Holland and Elder Oaks. That seemed like a really neat family of 13 that they interviewed. I enjoyed Elder Jensen's testimony about missionary work. I thought they did a fair job of presenting both angles of most of the issues. If you watched, I'd love to hear what you thought.